A friend of mine was telling me that he has a dog that keeps circling around the stock and he has a hard time stopping it. This dog came from a friend of his who trained it for him.
It was interesting when he showed me the problem. He brought some sheep into a yard and the sheep immediately went to the high point. The dog began to circle as he was having trouble moving them. I asked him how he had trained the dog. He said that a friend had trained the dog and that it had been trained in a round pen.
My opinion on round pens is, it is a good place to train out the natural instinct of a dog. It makes training a dog to specific commands relatively quick and easy. Also, when training in a round pen so many people think that is a good place to train balance. What is balance to a herding dog, or should I say working dog? To a working dog it is not a 12 and 6 placing, it is balancing on the head of the sheep in relation to you. It could be a 9 and 12 position.
Again, it is my opinion, if you are going to train a working dog do it where you are going to use it. GET RID OF ROUND PENS. This should be come a mantra.